Monday, July 27, 2015

"Illegitimate"

From Paige Nichols -- 

Probation Condition Aimed at Reducing Out-of-Wedlock Children is Itself Illegitimate

Thought you'd heard it all when it comes to supervised-release conditions? In United States v. Harrisa district court judge in Kansas City, Missouri, sua sponte ordered the defendant not to engage in unprotected sex without probation's approval. Was Harris a sex case? Not even close. It was a gun case. But the judge heard that Mr. Harris had fathered ten "illegitimate" children with seven different women, and he wanted to fix what he saw as a "serious social problem." The Eighth Circuit vacated the condition, finding it unrelated to Mr. Harris's gun crime, unrelated to deterrence from future criminal conduct, and unrelated to Harris's correctional treatment.



No comments:

Post a Comment